Theoryland Archive

Who said that they're attacking?

📁 What army is about to attack Caemlyn? 👤 Captain Cauthon 📅 2003-01-06 💬 3 replies
I don't believe that it is said at any point that they army approaching Caemlyn is definitely coming to lay siege. Sure, Elayne orders that preparations just in case, but that's just being sensible. There's nothing to say that whoever it is isn't coming with the intention of helping her. <br>That said, out of all the possibilities that people have already named, it seemed to me at least like the most probable answers are either the loyal Andorans sent east by Rahvin, Gawyn, or even better, a combination of the two. Gawyn is well aware by the end of book 6 that Elaida would prefer him dead, and word that Elayne has declared for the throne might be what it would take to pry him from the Tower. He would surely bring his Younglings with him and even likely increase their numbers throughout the march. Although they would be unlikely to have reached 20,000 by the time they reached Andor, I think it's possible if they met up with the Andoran loyalists to the east, who would certainly follow Gawyn. <br>I think it unlikely that the Andoran Houses could summon an army that large, especially in the dead of winter. Remembering how awestruck people are of national armies hitting the five digit mark in the earlier books, that only SOME houses could raise a force of that size seems unlikely. The Whitecloaks would have to come from the west or south as they do not have access to Travelling. As was pointed out earlier, the Shaido have numerous foes nearby that could crush them with ease. The Asha'man have no need for 20,000 men. Egwene is outside Tar Valon. The Murandians are busy playing the Game of Houses with the Band of the Red Hand, which Talmanes said he is moving southward. The other nations are too busy with their own problems.

Anything written here will not be posted.

Replies (3)

Tamyrlin #1
2003-01-06
I have read Crossroads of Twilight which may shed some light on this situation. I don't think it would be right of me to mislead or lead anyone before they read it.
heronblade #2
2003-06-18
it is possible it is a peaceful force, but if that is the case then why did they split into groups and why did they come so close without sending a messenger to warn of there pressence. generally, the only reason you sneek up on people in large numbers isn't to ask for a cup of suger
sarutobi #3
2005-05-08
Wasn't it said that this force outside of caemlyn is a rival opposing elyanes claim to the throne?